Popular notions about leadership still focus on an individual who stands alone from the crowd as a result of some special qualities, often defined in terms of charisma, which derives from the Greek word χαρισμα (khárisma) meaning literally ‘divine gift’. Already a member? The sign that stands on the spot where she boarded the bus, certainly does nothing to dispel this view. A great deal has been written on leadership. Before I started my address I went back to some of the many people who share any achievements of ‘my’ Presidential year. Challenges to the Introduction of an Alternative Leadership Style: A School Principal’s Journey in the Introduction of an “Ubuntu Leadership Model. I need you to be you, in order to for me to be me.’. I scanned the scrap of paper and posted it on Twitter with a request for comments and additions. I am still in awe of the improviser’s art, and since I’ve been doing research based in Edinburgh for the past few years, I’ve had the opportunity to visit the fringe festival and watch many improv performances. Yet I think history shows us that it can be considerably more effective. But worldviews are als... Ubuntu: A transformative leadership philosophy - Ncube - 2010 - Journal of Leadership Studies - Wiley Online Library The ancient Indian parable of the blind men and the elephant is relevant here. When they returned to the village, the first announced confidently ‘This being is like a thick snake!’ The second interrupted ‘you are quite mistaken, this beast is flat and broad like a fan!’ Another interjected ‘no, no, an elephant is a solid pillar like a tree-trunk’. Evoking practices, such as … I’ve served in BPS voluntary roles continuously for over 20 years, so have attended my fair share of Presidential addresses, although I never imagined giving one myself. I’m a big fan of the USA and its people. This definition is similar to Northouse's (2007, p3) definition — Leadership is a process You might even have notes or a manual to guide you. Another, who had grasped the tail, said ‘you are all mistaken, an elephant is like a rope!’ If the village had only listened to one of the blind men, and perhaps he had written books and given TED talks, our view of an elephant would be quite incomplete. Our leaders is just we ourselves!’. This provides not only stability, but also the opportunity to share water and nutrients between trees. Shared leadershipA few years ago, I visited the Southern states of the USA as part of research into the civil rights movement. It is also increasingly about worldviews or visions of life—beliefs, values, and principles. I will finish with my favourite of all the many leadership quotes from the Taoist philosopher Lao Tzu, with, if you will permit me, my own small addition at the end. Miller TW & Miller JM 2001. Msila, V (2014) Challenges to the introduction of an alternative leadership style: A school principal’s journey in the introduction of an ‘Ubuntu Leadership Model’. NHS Confederation, London. You would think, therefore, that our beliefs about leadership must be built upon a pretty solid foundation. However, it turns out that Rosa Parks wasn’t the first Black person to refuse to give up their seat on a bus. When I visited the forests where they grow naturally, a park ranger told me, to my surprise, that I could have found some in the UK. I had the privilege of travelling with him to many parts of the world. Ubuntu leadership model is characterized by the following principles: trustworthiness, respect, responsibility, fairness, compassion caring, and good citizenship. If you saw me delivering the address, sitting alone in the little box in the corner of your computer screen, or if you are reading these words now, you might think that somehow I had got to this lofty perch solely as a result of my own efforts. Discovering the Spirit of Ubuntu Leadership introduces a new leadership model which takes into account the history, culture and economic environment of African women leaders to understand, discover, observe and share their personal leadership experiences. Later that evening, after the first successful day of the Boycott, 6000 people crammed into the church, or gathered outside, to hear Dr King’s powerful words, that he had written only minutes before: ‘There comes a time when people get tired of being trampled over by the iron feet of oppression. Trying to stick to your ‘script’ in those circumstances is detrimental to the client and also to the practitioner – improvisation is called for. Coronavirus, Mental Health, Autism, Art, Racism, Gender, Trauma, Sport, Children, Workplace, Memory, Health Psychology, Emotion, Politics, Therapy, Suicide, School, Abuse, Prison, War, Replication, Media, Language, Brain Injury, Freud, Stress, Forensic, Sexuality, Music, Dementia, Behaviour Change, Parenting, Ethics, Intelligence, Climate Change, Internet, Writing, Addiction, Refugees, Culture, Students, Conflict, Humour, Leadership, Teaching, Religion, Qualitative, Education, Depression, Environmental, © Copyright 2000-2020 The British Psychological Society, The British Psychological Society is a charity registered in England and Wales, Registration Number: 229642 and a charity registered in Scotland, Registration Number: SC039452, VAT Registration Number: 283 2609 94. The Academy of Management Journal, 50, 1217-1234. There seem to me to be two possible explanations for this observation: 1) Leadership only happens in the UK and USA or 2) Our understanding of leadership has been coming from a rather limited perspective, and one perhaps in which the ‘hero leader model’ is more dominant. After teaching her morning classes, Robinson and her students distributed the leaflets across the whole of Montgomery via other members of the Women’s Political Council. Following Colvin’s arrest, a delegation including E.D. He faced hardships throughout his life but always modelled dignity and respect for everyone, whatever their station. My normal mode would have been to elaborate and revise it over the course of the next week or two and perhaps circulate it to a few trusted colleagues for their comments. Rather there were multiple leaders who shared the activities of leadership. Ubuntu as a Leadership Philosophy Ubuntu is a term derived from the Bantu Nguni languages of Zulu, Xhosa, Swati, and Ndebele. There comes a time.’, The boycott eventually came to an end, not through the capitulation of the local authorities, but through a case brought in the Federal court by Fred Gray, the 24-year-old protégé of Clifford Durr, on behalf of the four women who had been charged earlier in 1955, including Claudette Colvin. Ubuntu leadership is an African management philosophy, which is rooted in the African cultures, value system and beliefs, to provide the practical way for the efficient and effective running of organizations in Africa, with the aim of having a global competitiveness. Ubuntu Principles for Leadership Model. Some describe Ubuntu as an organizational culture (e.g. 2.3.3 CAN UBUNTU LEADERSHIP SYSTEM BE RELIED UPON Indeed, it’s not uncommon for leaders to ardently believe that myth themselves. (2011) states that In the case of education it means adoption of a … Their voices are notably absent among the books on leadership. Carson, J., Tesluk, P., & Marrone, J. What Claudette Colvin was saying was not that there was no leadership, nor that no leaders were required, but rather that there was not one single ‘heroic’ leader. These few words are just the coda. However, as I was preparing my address, the penny dropped. Robinson learned of Parks’ arrest in the late evening. Challenges to the introduction of an alternative leadership style: A school principal’s journey in the introduction of an “Ubuntu leadership model”. Many years on, when I was director of the clinical psychology programme at the University of Oxford, I had a framed picture of the coastal redwood trees in California in my office. Parks’ role seemed brave but passive, whereas it was the leadership of Dr King, standing apart from the crowd, which led the community to action. We can also hear this narrative in the news on a daily basis; a ‘super-head’ teacher has been brought in to ‘turn-around’ a failing school, or a ‘visionary’ new CEO has arrived at a company to ‘drive up performance’. Nixon, the President of the local chapter of the Black civil rights organisation, the NAACP, and Jo Anne Robinson, the Chairperson of the Montgomery Women’s Political Council, met with city commissioners to protest and even threated a bus boycott. Patricia developed the improvisation programme at Stanford, and although she retired some years ago, she continues to teach adult education classes in Improvisation. David Murphy, British Psychological Society President 2019-2020, gave his Presidential Address at the online conference. Most White immigrants arrived alone, or with their immediate family unit, almost all with the hope of making a better life through their own endeavours via free enterprise. One of the things that really struck me about the improv group is how much they support each other, just like the redwood trees. The most interesting human application of the Ubuntu integral leadership approach is that Ubuntu was at … Ubuntu is part of the African indigenous knowledge (AIK) and Hoberg (2004) argues that AIK should enable school leaders to lead schools effectively with what they have rather than what they are given. Gerada, C. (2013) Trust me... I’m a leader. The 25 ‘best books’ have a total of 32 authors, and all but one of these authors is male (i.e. Ubuntu thus empowers all to be valued to reach their full potential in accord with all around them. Àš¸Åš7ãÙÇÁ3^>lh®Ã7j,¸]@߂gcÌUV…'êvù3ëþ„rêRûOVÿ=ÙØ+ˆÐ Á4#EXÎ ï+æ_B“5NڟçùÿÆÕåqu_›8Në+ÙXÍ$ç&WI>rŽŽ'Þ¶.%Š1Žu’-Ôr6üqD In contrast, Dr King wasn’t even aware of Parks’ arrest until later on Friday morning, when Nixon called him to tell him of the plan, and that he had arranged a meeting that afternoon to be held in King’s own church since it was the largest venue! The mission of Ubuntu draws a very diverse community of participants and collaborators and contributors, who have wildly different interests and goals. 1. I spent the next 24 hours straight responding to comments from around the world. Ubuntu leadership implementation. Some of the outputs, which have received praise here in the UK and around the world, can be seen at www.bps.org.uk/coronavirus-resources. I even went back to see one improv show three times, as I couldn’t believe they really produced a different show every day based on pulling audience ideas out of a hat. Indeed, an intriguing 2010 study of culture and the perception of the leader’s position, led by Tanya Menon, found that Americans represent leaders standing ahead of groups, whereas Asians represent ‘back leaders’ standing behind groups. The principles of Ubuntu: Using the legal clinical model to train agents of social change 9 9 Principles of servant leadership and Ubuntu create a framework for developing a relational worldview. ‘Arch’ explained that ‘we are human through relationships, we become human through relationships. Indeed, he later wrote that, when he was asked the following Monday afternoon to lead the MIA, the organisation established to co-ordinate the boycott, ‘The action caught me unawares, it happened so quickly that I did not have time to think it through, if I had it is probable that I would have declined the nomination’. The Black community in Montgomery, Alabama, staged an almost total boycott of the city bus system that lasted over a year, and resulted in the end of the system of segregated seating and the birth of the modern civil rights movement, with Dr Martin Luther King at its helm. Nor was Rosa the passive, apolitical, character of the dominant narrative. However, the secret of the redwood’s success is that its roots grow out to a diameter of 100 feet and are interconnected with those of many other trees. Leadership has seldom been studied in the context of "humanness", a cultural philosophical practice that embodies a ubiquitous spirit of community, generosity and compassion to others' needs. 6µçôÔÉ Lû˜‹»T»Lޜ[Á±äw Ï|z8}[úHQp“g~IƢȋ89«³Œ˜‹D“ÆNv‹&é‚S ñhZ_~GVŽ”c–C§äClbƒSäڤϰY9ëRpm°º¤Q%Âq¯Í¤M]W£èÀE2ª2rÃ>RKÖo ̊ÊÌüLrŒŒÓ썩´ kÊOùPQ¿ $Žƒ In Search of Ubuntu Leadership Msila (2008) argues that there is a great potential in a model of leadership that utilizes ubuntu philosophy in schools. Google Scholar Ubuntu mode of leadership requires a departure from a hierarchical structure to communal involvement, embracing support in collective solidarity or commonality. Of course, the ancestors of the majority of Black Americans have a very different history, arriving as slaves either directly to the USA, or via the Caribbean. Ubuntu is central to indigenous governance systems and can be central to modern governance. However, its history is quite distinct from most other countries; over 95 per cent of the population are descendants of those who arrived within the last 200 years. No rider – no matter how strong – can win without cooperating with others.’. PERCEPTIONS REGARDING THE IMPACT OF UBUNTU AND SERVANT LEADERSHIP ON EMPLOYEE ENGAGEMENT IN THE WORKPLACE By ROGER MULLER (192035150) Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY: BUSINESS MANAGEMENT to be awarded at the Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University 2) Our understanding of leadership has been coming from a rather limited perspective, and one perhaps in which the ‘hero leader model’ is more dominant. Ubuntu-inspired leadership is substantial for responding, in an African way, to the needs of schools seeking to improve their performance. The sociologist Max Weber described charisma in relation to leaders as a ‘certain quality of an individual personality, by virtue of which he is set apart from ordinary men and treated as endowed with supernatural, superhuman, or at least specifically exceptional powers or qualities. Ubuntu leadership combines many of the most researched theories and philosophies of leadership and employs practical, tangible learnings that apply to all of us as leaders. In her book, Patricia lists 10 ‘improv maxims’. Over the next two days, we recruited members to the coordinating group, including a clinical psychologist with experience of international humanitarian work who I had not known until she responded to the tweet. Discovering the Spirit of Ubuntu Leadership introduces a new leadership model which takes into account the history, culture and economic environment of African women leaders to understand, discover, observe and share their personal leadership experiences. LEADERSHIP THEORIES AND MODELS 1. This ‘delicate network of inter-relationships’ is also widely recognised in the natural world. 'Discovering the Spirit of Ubuntu Leadership' introduces a new leadership model which takes into account the history, culture and economic environment of those being studied. Society needs to take a giant leap forward and we need a guiding paradigm to enable that leap. The Ubuntu Leadership Team aims to be a community resource that helps gather, build, and form a leadership training forum within the Ubuntu Community. The meeting was attended by all the local ministers, of which King was a relatively junior member, being only 26 years of age and having only arrived in Alabama to take his first ministerial position the previous year. Second, it presents an â Ubuntu as leadership philosophyâ framework that shows how Ubuntu can be applied practically as a leadership model. More relevant than her job as a seamstress in a department store, but notably absent from the sign, are the facts that Parks had served as the secretary of the local NAACP since 1943, had attended a residential leadership course at Highlander Folk school that summer led by Septima Clark, the ‘grandmother of the civil rights movement’ and, just four days before her arrest, attended a meeting about the recent acquittal of the murders of Black teenager, Emmett Till. It has been in use only for about two hundred years, although the term leader, from which it was derived, appeared as early as A.D. 1300 (Stogdill, 1974). To be fair to me, I’m not the only one to be guilty of this; most accounts of the movement are written through similar lenses. These ideas remain prominent in our narratives about leadership today. A leader is best when people barely know he exists, when his work is done, his aim fulfilled, they will say: we did it ourselves… and they will be right. available in full on the BPS YouTube channel, The sign that stands on the spot where she boarded the bus, View the complete article as a PDF document, Veterans, horses and the rediscovery of ‘with’, ‘Many of us are not optimally using our concentration span’, Coping with life in isolation and confinement during the Covid-19 pandemic, Why I no longer wish to be associated with the BPS. We are all connected and rely on others, just like the redwood trees. We want a productive, happy and agile community that can welcome new ideas in a complex field, improve every process every year, and foster collaboration between groups with very different needs, interests and skills. Ngomane, M. (2019) Everyday Ubuntu – Living better together, the African Way. notion of ‘Ubuntu’ leadership, but that such an oversimplified understanding of African leadership can easily contribute to gender discrimination. LeadershipI’ve been studying and teaching about leadership in one form or another for many years, and over the past few years had the privilege of leading a longitudinal study of leadership development in early career psychologists based at the University of Edinburgh. People suggested additions, made links with areas of existing work, and highlighted specific potential psychological contributions. Nelson, 2003); others describe Ubuntu as a potential ethically and culturally based leadership model without defining its specific behaviors (e.g. ), and my early experience of studying ecology was hugely beneficial. As Mungi Ngomane, Arch’s granddaughter, and author of the 2019 book Everyday Ubuntu, said recently in an interview ‘The self-made man is a myth, I’ve never yet met anyone who gave birth to themselves!’. On the other side, literature does One day the residents of a village inhabited by blind people learn that an elephant is passing through the area; having no experience of the animal they sent a party out to report back. This might sound more straightforward, but in fact I believe it requires more skilful leaders to interact with considerably more coordination than a single heroic leadership model. Many leadership challenges are not so predictable. I have found her work incredibly useful myself, and also relevant in clinical psychology training. Clare Gerada, former President of the Royal College of General Practitioners, has used the analogy of a peloton in the cycle race to describe this type of leadership. My own research has found that early career psychologists see leaders being significantly more ‘dominant’, ‘dynamic’, ‘pushy’ and ‘male’ than themselves. It concludes with some summarizing comments. If you type the word ‘leadership’ into an image search you will find images of a man (or occasionally a woman) standing out in front of the crowd, often on top of a giant arrow or on the top of a mountain, often pointing or holding a telescope or steering wheel (as in the example to the left). It’s all too common to pull out an extract of someone’s life and look at it in isolation, but this gives a distorted picture. the principal in it used ubuntu as a form of a leadership model. ), they have been delivering their address through their actions for a whole year. They identify a number of facilitating factors: a shared purpose (clear understanding of a shared goal, team members providing practical and emotional support to one another, trust), encouraging openness and candour, and voice (ensuring that each team member’s contribution is heard and valued). Students must have got fed up of hearing me using it as an analogy for recognising the importance of support from others. Covid-19As the reality of the Covid crisis became apparent earlier this year, I drew on the principles of improv once again. The author combines the African philosophy of Ubuntu or humanness, the cornerstone of African thought and life, with the concept of Integral Leadership, with particular reference to Lessem and Schieffer’s combining, in their 2010 book Integral Research and Innovation, of nature and community, culture and spirituality, science and technology, and politics and economies. Well, yes…and no. However, the coastal redwood grown on its own will only grow to a fraction of its usual height, will be pale in colour and is unlikely to live very long. They pay constant attention to where the other is going, and get ready to pick up the thread, or to step in, if their partner is beginning to struggle. Shared Leadership in Teams: An Investigation of Antecedent Conditions and Performance. This philosophy also responds to the local African context, hence it might be ideal for African The extent of the discrepancy between their own view of themselves and their beliefs about leaders, correlates with their motivation to engage in leadership roles, which among psychologists is often low. Also, my father-in-law, who passed away at the very start of my Presidential year. Throughout the BPS Covid response we have explicitly drawn on the principles of shared leadership. A lecturer at Alabama State College, she went back to work that night where she and two students hand-printed a staggering 35,000 leaflets calling for a bus boycott the following Monday, the day scheduled for Parks’ trial. The night Rosa Parks was arrested, Nixon, and civil rights lawyer, Clifford Durr, went to make her bail. In her 2005 book Improv Wisdom: Don’t Prepare, Just Show Up, she applies the principles of Improv to everyday life. A leader needs to be well educated, highly qualified and inspiring. He has created a new socio-economic model that sounds in the minds of Africans. Ubuntu is about showing humanity to one another: the word itself captures the spirit of being human. But when the client walks in, they reveal something completely unexpected. These are summarised by Jay Carson and colleagues in a 2007 Academy of Management Journal article. To be clear, I think most of the books on the list are excellent – I found I had 22 of them on my bookshelf, and had even read most of them! However, responding to crises requires coming together across silos, although not at the expense of existing, valued networks. There are many aspects of the ‘heroic leader’ model that make it dangerous and counterproductive. {b„F¯Òmyʾ­RZ`”gŠd2æ+Ÿ\ꓲ{*j+ñx¦riÇߔÔ=&%ÁÔ bÀ¼Á¯ÃցÊéA¹š™\TcmÞ Indeed, every single book was written either in the USA (94 per cent) or the UK (6 per cent), apart from The Art of War (which seems to be much more popular in the USA and the UK than it is in China!). The departure in structure might be a call for the church to consider making laity involvement more conspicuous. One I have personally been particularly concerned with is how it alienates those who work in health professions. When asked by the attorney for the city if she and the others had a leader when they began protesting the segregation laws, she replied ‘Did we have a leader? Indeed, an intriguing 2010 study of culture and the perception of the leader’s position, led by Tanya Menon, found that Americans represent leaders standing ahead of groups, whereas Asians represent ‘back leaders’ standing behind groups. However, through our longitudinal research we’ve found that early-career psychologists can, and do, develop into confident leaders through a process of identifying their own leadership strengths within but also developing a different model of leadership. The next day, I sat down to begin to wonder what this would actually consist of! There comes a time, my friends, when people get tired of being plunged across the abyss of humiliation, where they experience the bleakness of nagging despair.